Can Domestic Violence Laws Be Misused? A Legal Perspective

Domestic violence laws exist to protect women from abuse within the household.
However, a common question raised is whether these laws can be misused
and how courts deal with such situations.

Indian courts have repeatedly clarified that while protection of genuine victims is essential,
fairness and due process must be maintained for all parties.

What Is the Purpose of Domestic Violence Law?

The primary purpose of domestic violence law is protection, safety, and dignity
of women facing abuse in domestic relationships.

It is not intended to punish without examination or to be used as a tool for harassment.
Courts consistently emphasise this balance.

Have Courts Acknowledged Possibility of Misuse?

Yes.

Courts have acknowledged that, like many protective laws,
domestic violence provisions can be misused in some cases.

This recognition does not weaken the law.
Instead, it ensures that:

• ✔ Genuine victims receive protection
• ✔ False or exaggerated claims are examined carefully
• ✔ Innocent persons are not mechanically proceeded against

How Do Courts Guard Against Misuse?

Courts do not grant relief blindly.
They examine:

• Consistency of allegations
• Specific details of incidents
• Conduct of both parties
• Probability of events

Vague, general, or sweeping allegations are viewed with caution,
especially when multiple family members are named without specific roles.

Are All In-Laws Automatically Liable?

No.

Mere relationship with the husband does not automatically make in-laws liable.
There must be clear involvement or specific conduct.

Courts have repeatedly discouraged naming every family member
without concrete allegations.

Does Filing a DV Case Mean Automatic Guilt?

No.

Filing a domestic violence complaint does not mean that allegations are presumed to be true.

Each case is examined on:

• Evidence
• Circumstances
• Credibility of claims

Relief is granted only when the court is satisfied that protection is genuinely required.

What Remedies Exist Against False or Exaggerated Claims?

Indian law provides remedies against abuse of legal process.
Depending on facts, courts may:

• Dismiss unsubstantiated complaints
• Refuse interim relief
• Limit proceedings to relevant parties

The legal system aims to discourage misuse while preserving access for genuine cases.

Balancing Protection and Fairness

Domestic violence law operates on a balance:

• Protecting women from abuse
• Ensuring fairness to the accused
• Preventing mechanical or retaliatory litigation

This balance is central to the credibility of the law itself.

Key Takeaway

Domestic violence laws are necessary and important.
At the same time, courts are alert to misuse and insist on careful examination of facts.

Protection and fairness are not opposing goals — both are essential.

This article is written by the academic team at Delhi Law Academy, Jaipur, for general legal awareness.

📘 Stay Ahead with Delhi Law Academy!

Get access to free monthly current affairs, read our insightful blogs,
and explore free study resources prepared by experts at DLA Jaipur. 🚀

❓ Frequently Asked Questions