books comparing ipc and bns

BNS vs IPC: Offences Against Women & Children

Delhi Law Academy Criminal Law Leave a Comment

Silhouette of a woman looking empowered



Offences Against Women & Children: IPC vs BNS

πŸ‘©β€βš–οΈ Offences Against Women & Children: IPC vs BNS

πŸ“Œ Key Topics in this Blog

  • 🚨 Rape & Sexual Assault – IPC vs BNS
  • πŸ‘§ Child Protection Offences – IPC vs BNS
  • 🏠 Domestic Violence & Cruelty
  • πŸ“Š Comparison Table
  • πŸ“– Case Law & Examples
  • πŸ”— Links to Pillar & Ancillary Blogs

πŸ“– Introduction

Protection of women and children is a fundamental objective of criminal law in India. The Indian Penal Code (IPC) has historically provided a detailed framework to address sexual offences, harassment, and offences affecting children, while the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) modernizes these provisions, simplifying language, clarifying definitions, and consolidating overlapping sections. Judicial aspirants must understand these changes to navigate both examination questions and practical legal applications effectively. This blog provides a comprehensive comparison of IPC and BNS provisions regarding offences against women and children.

🚨 Rape & Sexual Assault – IPC vs BNS

Under the IPC, Sections 375–376 define rape, Section 354 addresses assault or harassment of women, and Section 509 criminalizes words, gestures, or acts intended to insult a woman’s modesty. BNS retains the essence of these offences but simplifies language, emphasizes consent, and clarifies the definitions of age, mental capacity, and consent.

Definition and Key Elements

In IPC, rape involves sexual intercourse without consent, with exceptions for marital relations under certain conditions. BNS refines this by specifying “act by which sexual penetration is committed without free consent” and removes ambiguity. Sexual harassment is broadened to include all forms of unwelcome physical or verbal conduct in professional or public spaces.

Illustrative Examples

  • Workplace harassment: unsolicited advances, inappropriate gestures.
  • Marital situations: mental and physical coercion clarified under BNS.
  • Child sexual abuse: BNS provides clearer age definitions and emphasizes reporting obligations.

Exam-Oriented Notes

  • BNS clarifies consent and age thresholds, making examination scenarios easier to analyze.
  • Focus on differentiating assault, harassment, and rape based on intent, coercion, and victim age.

πŸ‘§ Child Protection Offences – IPC vs BNS

IPC Sections 363–373 cover kidnapping, abduction, and illegal removal of children, as well as child labour. BNS consolidates these provisions, emphasizing the child’s best interest, and clarifies responsibilities for reporting and intervention.

Key Differences

  • BNS explicitly defines ‘child’ and sets clear age limits for offences.
  • Consolidates offences involving abduction, trafficking, and exploitation.
  • Highlights reporting responsibilities of guardians, institutions, and public officials.

Examples & Practical Applications

  • Abduction for sexual exploitation or forced labour.
  • Illegal adoption or trafficking of children.
  • Child neglect and abuse in institutional settings.

Exam Tips

  • Understand intent and coercion distinctions between IPC and BNS.
  • Memorize key sections consolidated under BNS for child protection.

🏠 Domestic Violence & Cruelty – IPC 498A, 304B vs BNS

Domestic violence and cruelty provisions address physical, mental, and emotional abuse. IPC Section 498A covers cruelty by husband or relatives, while 304B addresses dowry deaths. BNS retains the legal essence but simplifies clause structure for clarity.

Key Changes in BNS

  • Language simplification for cruelty, mental harassment, and dowry-related offences.
  • Clearer definitions of abuser, victim, and evidentiary requirements.
  • Enhanced focus on mental cruelty alongside physical abuse.

Examples

  • Persistent mental harassment leading to suicidal tendencies.
  • Physical abuse linked to dowry demands.
  • Neglect or forced isolation of women in domestic settings.

πŸ“Š Comparison Table: IPC vs BNS

Offence IPC Section BNS Equivalent Key Notes / Changes
Rape & Sexual Assault 375–376, 354, 509 Rape & Assault Consent, age, and capacity emphasized; language simplified; punishments retained.
Child Protection 363–373 Child Protection Age & intent clarified; BNS consolidates sections; examples updated for clarity.
Domestic Violence & Cruelty 498A, 304B Cruelty & Dowry Death Essence retained; clauses simplified; clearer wording for evidentiary standards.

πŸ“– Case Law & Examples

  • State of Rajasthan v. Kiran: Defines scope of assault and consent in rape laws.
  • Sakshi v. Union of India: Clarifies harassment and mental cruelty in domestic violence cases.
  • Child abduction and trafficking examples highlight BNS consolidation and clearer definitions.

πŸ“ Key Takeaways for Judicial Aspirants

❓ Frequently Asked Questions – Offences Against Women & Children

BNS simplifies language, emphasizes consent, age, and capacity, but legal essence and punishments remain the same as IPC.

BNS consolidates child-related sections and emphasizes best interest of the child, age, intent, and consent clarity.

Clauses simplified, wording clearer for evidentiary standards, but cruelty, dowry death, and punishments remain unchanged.

No, BNS retains the punishments but organizes sections more clearly for ease of interpretation.

BNS retains IPC exceptions; aspirants should be aware of ongoing legal interpretations and case law.

πŸ“˜ Stay Ahead with Delhi Law Academy!

Get access to free monthly current affairs, read our insightful blogs,
and explore free study resources prepared by experts at DLA Jaipur. πŸš€

Contact us

πŸ“ Delhi Law Academy – Jaipur Branch
6C, Tower 2, Coaching Hub, Pratap Nagar, Jaipur – 302033

πŸ“ž Phone:
+91 9911916552
+91 8447285606

βœ‰οΈ Email:
contactus@delhilawacademy.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *